Upon the former defender assumed control as the club's head coach in the winter, there was scant opportunity to find his feet. A congested fixture schedule meant a phased integration to his group of players was simply not feasible.
Spanish media highlighted the challenges he would face, especially handling a dressing room containing some of soccer's biggest personalities.
But forging positive connections with the squad members appeared not to worry the ex- Liverpool defender.
"That is not an aspect that worries me greatly," the coach stated at his introductory press briefing.
Eight weeks since, he says those rapports are developing further and the outcomes on the pitch are reflecting that.
Building Bonds
During the spring, the Madrid boss guided his side to victories against teams managed by elite tacticians: the Portuguese manager's the Lisbon side, the Catalan's City and Diego Simeone's Atletico Madrid.
Real Madrid are still a quartet of points behind the Spanish league leaders Barcelona, with a potentially title-deciding El Clasico in May, while their European campaign rolls on with a quarter-final encounter against Bayern Munich.
The team's performances are getting better and the chemistry between the coach and players are developing.
"I am becoming to comprehend the players more and more," said the head coach following Real Madrid's 3-2 victory against rivals Atletico Madrid last week.
"I came in at a juncture when I almost had insufficient time to train with the squad, to grasp where they were at ease, and to see how they gelled with one another."
He acknowledged the circumstances of his hiring posed fresh difficulties.
"For me, it's difficult to arrive mid-season and observe how the team operates, and that's what has evolved over these past eight weeks," he went on.
"At present I know my players personally and professionally, where I can get the peak output from them, and where I can make adjustments."
Plaudits for Vinicius Jr
A key individual thriving under the new manager is the Brazilian winger.
He has been in the starting lineup for 16 of his new coach's 17 games in charge, with his output also rising markedly - he has found the back of the net 11 times under Arbeloa, versus scoring just six in 27 appearances under his predecessor.
Arbeloa has focused on restoring the attacker's self-belief, pushing him to express himself and be creative rather than restricting him in terms of tactics.
"I'm lucky to have Vini, he's cherished by all the fans. We want to see the Vinicius who has fun on the pitch, who smiles, who dances… that is the Vini I want to see," he said in his initial press conference in charge.
This method differs from accounts of friction under Alonso, with the forward reportedly saying "I will quit this club" after being substituted in last Clasico.
The new boss has openly stood up for him, emphasizing he is fully backed by the coaches and the entire squad.
"He's one of the deadliest footballers, if not the most dangerous, in the world and he represents what a this club's player is," said Arbeloa.
The Brazilian put discussions about his long-term prospects on hold last summer but, last week, he made his commitment clear.
"I am solely focused on this club and staying there for a long time," he informed the media before Brazil's friendly match with the French team.
Valverde Regains Form Again
The Uruguayan midfielder's form has also skyrocketed since Arbeloa arrived.
During the tenure of Alonso, he registered three strikes and seven goal contributions from 31 games.
Ever since the manager's appointment, he has been named in the starting eleven for each of the 17 of his matches in charge, netting on seven occasions and providing five assists.
A key factor has been a change in role to his natural place in midfield.
During Alonso's time in charge, the player at times struggled to nail down a regular place in his preferred position, being positioned in unfamiliar roles such as full-back.
Although the choice was partly because of injuries to other players, Valverde's displeasure was evident. "I was not born to be a right-back," he said.
But now, restored to his natural habitat, the midfielder is excelling.
He has netted six strikes in just a 30-day period, including a three-goal haul against City and a crucial goal in a 3–2 win over Atletico Madrid.
Fresh Faces, Greater Possibilities?
Arbeloa's background as boss of the club's Castilla side has made integrating academy talents into the senior side feel seamless, so it was expected to anticipate him to give promising youngsters minutes.
This was seen more notably when the team faced Elche recently and the coach gave minutes to six youth team players.
One player, in particular, has quickly established himself as one of the manager's most promising proteges.
Being only 18 years and 226 days old, he became the most youthful player in the team's records to start twice in the European Cup knockout stages, surpassing Vinicius' record by 10 days.
Asked what it meant to see five academy graduates on the pitch, he couldn't hide his joy.
"I think I can be content after a night like this one," he said.
"I was recently talking to two of them, who were the first players I coached when they were 13 or 14, and to be able to give them the opportunity to play at the Bernabeu is a dream come true for me."
While the coach might be familiar with the youth team members, he acknowledges injuries have limited his exposure